Root for the Underdog

So I started to tell you about my conversation with God where she asked me what I thought about Harry Potter, but then I got sidetracked on the issue of magic versus miracles.

Most of the conversation isn’t really worth repeating but I had one insight that I’d like to share. One of the most interesting things that Ms. Rowling managed to do, I think, is to preserve the sense that Harry is the underdog. Through his sort-of-captivity with the Dursleys and his status as Lord Voldemort’s primary adversary he gets to have the audience rooting for him as the underdog while still managing to cement his position as the most powerful student that Hogwart’s has hosted since Tom Riddle went there. He achieves feats the likes of which legends are made on, and still gets to be the long shot bet. It’s a pretty neat trick.

God allowed that it was a pretty good bit of literary legerdemain. She did however take the time to point out that there was precedent for such a feat. She pointed out the New Testament. Jesus Christ comes along. The direct son of God. The Messiah. The savior of all mankind. Yet he gets taken down by some mid-level bureaucrats who just want to stop the yammering of their subjects. A hero’s journey indeed.

RSS feed | Trackback URI

Comments »

No comments yet.

Your comment will be listed as by "some poor unfortunate soul."

Also, your comment will not appear on the site until it has been approved by a site administrator.

To avoid this, login to an existing account or create a new account.

Comment Rules

This site is intended for all ages, please act accordingly. Don't use words that many people consider offensive.

We really appreciate that you want to be part of the conversation, but please have something to say. Avoid comments that just say "me too" no matter what words you use to say it. If you just want to approve or disapprove of what somebody else said, that's what the comment ratings are for. Please try to get your spelling and grammar correct, this will help people to understand you. Try to say something constructive or at least attack ideas and not people.

Also, keep in mind that though you retain the copyright on what you write here, according to our Terms of Service, you grant us a license to use it both on the website and in related projects in any medium.

Thanks for listening, and thanks for commenting. Now go ahead.

Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong> in your comment.